APA Open Community

APA Members at Roundtable Discussion

 View Only
Expand all | Collapse all

Tracking Employee Productivity?

  • 1.  Tracking Employee Productivity?

    Posted 07-19-2023 18:59

    I'm exploring ways we can measure our employees' productivity. Does anyone have experience with productivity tracking or have you designed metrics for your business related to productivity?

    Now that we're past our real busy time, I'm seeing  several of our employees wasting a lot of time, turning 10-15 minute tasks into 30-40 minute projects. We've suggested several other projects these employees can spend time doing that would provide more value to our business but they continue to drag out jobs unnecessarily.

    Thanks in advance for any tips any of you can share.



    ------------------------------
    Judi Brown, Owner
    Tacoma Trophy
    4021 100th St SW #B, Lakewood WA 98499
    253.302.5566
    judi@tacomatrophy.com
    ------------------------------
    Netsoft Studio


  • 2.  RE: Tracking Employee Productivity?

    Posted 07-20-2023 07:32

    I'd recommend being very careful with this. Tracking metrics can have unintended side effects (like if you track time from order to ship, people might develop a tendency to skip QC or other critical steps). The only one I set is that we should try to respond to any customer email/voicemail within an hour if at all possible. If I notice something is sitting in a design or production queue for a couple days, I'll ask about it, but I don't necessarily track strict metrics. My experience has been no one wants to get asked about anything (in this industry or any other job), so that's deterrent enough.

    It hasn't really been an issue in my shop, but in other jobs I've worked I've found structured meetings/activities create time bounds to get people to focus. E.g. "I want to do a team happy hour on Thursday, but we can't do that until [insert annoying task here] is taken care of."

    What are they doing that's stretching the activities out so long? If it's socializing, maybe add in break times and then ask them to focus during other time periods. If it's playing with their phones, ask them to put their phones down for certain stretches of time (5 min checks every hour or something).  Structuring time and setting goals I think  will work better than tracking metrics. If you have specific projects you want them to work on, set a date or time that you want it completed.

    Also, personal opinion, maybe check in to see if they need a mental rest from the "real busy time." I don't know anyone who can be "on" 100% of the time, so maybe talk to them about who needs a break and how to work that into the schedule. I know we celebrate the down weeks almost as much as we celebrate the busy weeks...



    ------------------------------
    Shana Beach CRS
    Owner
    Chase Street Accessories & Engraving
    Baltimore MD
    833.332.4273 EXT300
    ------------------------------

    Netsoft Studio


  • 3.  RE: Tracking Employee Productivity?

    Posted 07-20-2023 17:37

    Thanks for your feedback Shana. 



    ------------------------------
    Judi Brown, Owner
    Tacoma Trophy
    4021 100th St SW #B, Lakewood WA 98499
    253.302.5566
    judi@tacomatrophy.com
    ------------------------------

    Netsoft Studio


  • 4.  RE: Tracking Employee Productivity?

    Posted 07-20-2023 10:18

    I'll second @Shana Beach on having a careful and intentional selection of metrics. If there's too much emphasis on speed, quality & accuracy might suffer. If your folks are overly concerned with quality, the speed might tank. I think it's human nature--if we're given 30 minutes to do a task it'll take 30 minutes. If we're given 60 minutes to do the same task, it'll probably end up taking 60 minutes. If their performance is connected to incentives, I'd measure on a few criteria: 

    • Speed / Quantity - an objective measure of how much work is getting done how fast
    • Quality / Accuracy - can be tracked via a quality control process, warranty claims, customer feedback
    • People Skills / Conduct - treating others with respect, showing up on time, limiting phone time

    A couple thoughts:  

    • Engage and reward your folks in process improvement efforts. Getting them thinking about areas of waste (materials, time) or friction points in the processes will likely identify improvements that will not only save time, but make their job easier/better. It shows them you care about their feedback as much as their performance. 
    • Not certain about the cadence of your work day, but perhaps some more structure around when folks are doing which tasks might help--if they're just working off a project list and an 8-hour bucket of time, it's likely that some tasks that deserve more attention get shorted, and some that could be quick get stretched out. Likely another opportunity to engage them in creating a more explicit production schedule, of sorts. 

    In any case, I think it's best practice to have their input on whatever guidelines / rules you'd like to implement, because having them involved will lead to better adoption. 

    Good luck!



    ------------------------------
    Chris Duerkop
    Gemini Inc
    Cannon Falls MN
    800.538.8377
    ------------------------------

    Netsoft Studio


  • 5.  RE: Tracking Employee Productivity?

    Posted 07-20-2023 17:39

    Thanks for your feedback and ideas Chris. Minimizing waste has been a theme for our conversations for several weeks now but we have some team members who don't equate wasted time to "waste."



    ------------------------------
    Judi Brown, Owner
    Tacoma Trophy
    4021 100th St SW #B, Lakewood WA 98499
    253.302.5566
    judi@tacomatrophy.com
    ------------------------------

    Netsoft Studio


  • 6.  RE: Tracking Employee Productivity?

    Posted 07-20-2023 17:23
    Edited by Corey Peterson 07-20-2023 17:24

    This is an excellent question and an issue many have to deal with. Would make a great roundtable discussion topic at the annual conference.



    ------------------------------
    Corey Peterson
    Hemslojd Inc
    Lindsborg KS
    785.554.5210
    ------------------------------

    Netsoft Studio


  • 7.  RE: Tracking Employee Productivity?

    Posted 07-21-2023 09:22

    I want to preface my thoughts on a couple things.  I manage a production department and am not signing the checks for the people in my department.  Each member of my production team has their own work area and equipment so with few exceptions they aren't sharing workspace.  I do track metrics related to volume, defects, equipment usage, etc. and each person has a certain expectations for error percentage and production volume.  However, as other commenters have noted, this can create unintended effects that aren't desirable.

    Volume and error expectations are set by what equipment they are using and their experience level.  Newer employees have lower volume and higher error rates which evolve as they do.  I set these numbers so each employee has an understanding of what "good" performance is but they also know that if we don't have the volume of orders to reach our volume expectations that it doesn't negatively reflect on them. 

    Errors are used as teaching tools.  It is very easy for people to obsess with their error rate if they feel it is a hammer waiting to drop on them.  The point I try to stress is that we use our errors to learn and improve skills understanding that we are human and mistakes happen.  Now it could certainly get to a point where it may impact their position with the company but overall I emphasize the fact that sometimes they will have a bad day or a bad week and that I'm looking for ownership of the mistake and the willingness to learn from it.

    Getting the team involved in reducing wastes or inefficiencies in the process is a great way for them to feel like their opinion matters and gives them some ownership of the process. I've tried the list of things to do when it's slow approach without much success.  Instead, giving individuals the responsibility for certain tasks and setting check ins and timeframes can help move projects along without you feeling like you need to constantly watch.

    As other people have mentioned, celebrating the slow times as a time to relax and reflect on the busy times is great.  People can relax and destress so they are ready for when it gets busy or that large order comes in.  Fun team events, lunches, competitions are a great way to build the strength of your team while not being traditionally productive.

    Good Luck!



    ------------------------------
    Dan Gerber
    Terrybear Urns and Memorials
    Saint Paul MN
    651.435.4163
    ------------------------------

    Netsoft Studio


  • 8.  RE: Tracking Employee Productivity?

    Posted 07-21-2023 10:34

    Judi,

    This is an excellent discussion.  Along this line there are some benefits that can be gleaned from Lean Manufacturing.  I've been a long time fan of Paul Akers and what he has done with his company FastCap.  I use some of his company's products in my operation, so have experienced his service first hand.  Take the time when you can to watch these videos below.  I have no doubt it will improve the situation you are having with your employees, and will give you some tools to change their mindset where your issues will be a thing of the past.



    ------------------------------
    David Takes
    Expressions Engraved
    Saint Joseph, MO
    816.232.6000
    ------------------------------

    Netsoft Studio


  • 9.  RE: Tracking Employee Productivity?

    Posted 07-21-2023 12:17

    Fantastic videos.  Makes you view your company and processes differently.  Well worth an hour of your time.  Thanks for sharing David



    ------------------------------
    Niels Norby
    Netsoft Studio, LLC
    775.996.1343 EXT1
    www.netsoftstudio.com
    ------------------------------

    Netsoft Studio


  • 10.  RE: Tracking Employee Productivity?

    Posted 07-22-2023 08:59

    Thanks David!



    ------------------------------
    David Cassens CRS
    Arista Trophies & Awards
    Bergenfield NJ
    201.665.0448
    ------------------------------

    Netsoft Studio


  • 11.  RE: Tracking Employee Productivity?

    Posted 07-23-2023 23:14

    Thanks! I finally had a chance to watch these videos...fantastic concepts to consider in our operations.



    ------------------------------
    Judi Brown, Owner
    Tacoma Trophy
    4021 100th St SW #B, Lakewood WA 98499
    253.302.5566
    judi@tacomatrophy.com
    ------------------------------

    Netsoft Studio